RR Interviews: WITHIN TEMPTATION ‘Resist’ Album Review

Photo by Set Vexy | Dokodemo
Article By: Kira Schlechter ‡ Edited By: Leanne Ridgeway

The word “resist” is everywhere these days. It’s usually used in a political context, such as in standing up against social subjection and authoritarianism. In the case of the Dutch band WITHIN TEMPTATION, it also extends to resisting continuing and ever more insidious intrusions into our personal privacy.

Those themes are central to the band’s latest album, titled, yes, ‘Resist.’ Singer, songwriter, and concerned world citizen Sharon den Adel found herself increasingly troubled by the recent world, and local, events.

“It’s the world upside down in a few years’ time, that’s what I feel,” den Adel said in an interview backstage prior to the band’s show with In Flames at The Fillmore in Philadelphia. She cited recent developments in Poland (whose government has passed increasingly more restrictive laws and has seen a rise in Islamophobia and xenophobia since being admitted to the European Union) and Hungary (which has cracked down on immigration and freedom of the press) as examples.

“I read a lot of newspapers and different sources to get a better picture,” she said. “It interests me very much how things have come about.

Even in her own country, the Netherlands, certain changes have occurred. Worried about election hacking in 2017, the government announced all ballots cast would be counted by hand instead of electronically.

Nobody trusts them (computers) anymore,” den Adel said, “That’s just a sign of the time that we’re doing something wrong.

“We (also) have a law that if you have a certain social background and also some indication that you have done criminal stuff in the past, it’s easier for (the government) to track you because you might be a risk in the future.

“Where does it end? We’ve gone too far in trying to get a grip on certain problems we have in society. We are living in a democracy, but that can turn around at any time. You can see it in different countries – it used to be a democracy, and (then) one president, one party in power, and they change so many things,” she added.

One song central to this theme is the one that kicks off the album, “The Reckoning.” With the trumpet-like keyboard riff that starts the track, it’s a clarion call to action and features Jacoby Shaddix of Papa Roach on vocals.

“We had our history in the past, we had our wars, everyone in every country,” she said. “We fought for freedom in the Western world, and in most countries, we got it. I think through everything that’s happening with technology nowadays, small pieces are taken away from us.

“You can’t undo technology. You created the bomb, but you can’t ever undo it; you can’t take away the technology. (The song is) about making a fist together as a community.”

Are we at a point of some sort of “reckoning?”

“We will always fight for freedom because we know what it is and we’ll never give it up,” she said. “Not that I’m saying call to arms, but it’s more like, if it comes down to it, that’s what will happen.

“You already see it – you see it in Austria because there’s a right-wing party there. You see a lot of people waking up. They are trying to get laws through the government without the people standing behind (them). There’s a lot of tension there, like it is in Poland (and) in Hungary. We have (spent) a lot of EU money to get them started with their economy and now they’re closing their borders. It’s the world upside down at the moment,” she reiterated.


Open in Spotify

Endless War” has a double meaning — the idea of fighting endless wars in various countries as well as fighting endless personal wars within ourselves.

“It’s your own uncertainty and your own worst enemy,” she said. “We never learn from our personal history, but also not worldwide history.”

Raise Your Banner,” too, is another call to action, with In Flames singer Anders Friden defiantly bellowing, “Blood for freedom!

I’m always for dialogue – I’m not for real wars,” she said. “I’m a very peaceful person. But it does give me this anger about why don’t we ever learn. It makes me really sad.

“I think maybe it’s also a realization of getting older (she is 44). When you’re younger, you think you’re going to change the world. And then coming to a certain point in your life, you think, OK, now I’m older and the world didn’t get better,” she added.

Holy Ground” alludes to the sexual abuse scandal rocking the Catholic Church.

There’s certain things you don’t do,” she said. “It’s boundaries – that’s what I call the ‘holy ground.’ This is off-limits, this is ‘me’ space that you have to respect.

“Some people just don’t and then when they don’t respect it, afterwards they’re denying that they even crossed it. And oh, that really gets me started,” she said with a wry laugh.

Den Adel is also a mom – her children are 13, 9, and 7 – so these sociopolitical issues, along with technology and the loss of privacy, hit especially close to home.

When I was growing up in the ‘80s, I never thought that the Internet or social media would ever be the way it is nowadays,” she said. “All the new technology was something that we all embrace, of course. We’re not against technology, but there’s also another side to it. I think people are starting to realize now how much it affects their lives.

Her children are not allowed on social media, she said – “only in closed groups so I know who their friends are and who may be watching.

I don’t want them being recognized on the Internet,” she said. “(And) what you post now, as a kid even – if they apply for a job, (a company can) backtrack you and they’ll know everything about you. You can’t erase things, not very easily. And a lot of these social media platforms say, whatever you post, we own it.”

Resist‘ also means resisting the inevitable calls to stay the same. Renowned for their symphonic sound laden with orchestral arrangements, this time around, WITHIN TEMPTATION looked to other sounds, like hip-hop and pop, for inspiration. There’s still plenty of symphonic touches – choral singing, the occasional strings, den Adel using the glorious operatic end of her voice – but those are used sparsely, as punctuation, not as the whole sentence.

Together for over 20 years, the band is den Adel, her husband, Robert Westerholt (he writes a lot of the music, but stays home with the children during tours), guitarist Stefan Helleblad, lead guitarist Ruud Jolie, keyboardist Martijn Spierenburg, bassist Jeroen van Veen, and drummer Mike Coolen.



Music is organic, it always changes,” she said. “If you are in music, you feel that change constantly and you try to keep up with it. We’ve been around for a long time now and we like to keep up because we like new sounds, we like to evolve. That’s the power of our band is that we still want to change and we’re looking for new bands to inspire us and we couldn’t find them in metal, unfortunately, at the time.

Subsequently, ‘Resist‘ sounds futuristic and ferociously modern. It’s a very heavy album, big and thunderous and bombastic at times, but not in the stereotypically metal ways of being “heavy.”

We have a lot of dark synths combined with guitars, for instance, to make a different kind of sound than we normally had,” den Adel said. “(Before), mostly it was guitars making it heavy, and of course this orchestra always in the background.

For us, it’s a very American album,” den Adel said. “And then everybody goes, no, it’s very European. What is typical European then? Because we left that orchestra out for (the most) part, which makes it very European. Keeping it more to guitars and those kinds of things, we thought it sounds more American.

“In Europe, there’s always piano underneath or synthesizers. We did it on certain places, but a lot of times we also kept it out — it’s like let’s give more space to the music,” she added.

Resist‘ was born from a very dark spot in WITHIN TEMPTATION’s timeline. A lengthy tour in support of their last album, ‘Hydra,’ coupled with the illness and subsequent passing of den Adel’s father at the end of that tour, along with wanting to change musically but not knowing exactly how, led to a case of writer’s block, the likes of which den Adel had not experienced before.

You can’t find the right words to express yourself anymore – you feel it, but you can’t make that transition or the translation,” she said. “I had a lot of emotions, maybe too much, and they were all fighting to get attention.

“I wasn’t even sure I wanted to go back to Within Temptation at the time because I just felt so emotional. I still couldn’t express myself. It was the heaviest period in a long time that I had,” she said.

What started her on the path back to the band was, weirdly enough, another type of songwriting – in the form of her solo album, ‘My Indigo,’ released last April. A more intimate effort, more pop than anything else and heavily influenced by urban music, ‘My Indigo‘ gave WITHIN TEMPTATION a new lease on life.

I really wanted to experiment,” she said. “When I write for Within Temptation, it has to sound in big lines, a certain way, and I was like, I’m not going to do that, I can’t write that powerful kind of song, I really want to have something more introverted.

“I tried a lot of new things and really had to figure out what kind of music I was actually making, because it just came out the way it came. (And) eventually we (the band) all sat together and it was like, OK, how are we going to continue with Within Temptation? And I said well, maybe we can use what I’ve learned from ‘My Indigo’ and see where it ends,” she added.

The transition was surprisingly seamless.

We did the same kind of production (as her solo album), but of course with the heavy guitars again, typical Within Temptation stuff,” she said. “It really helped make it sound more up to date.

One track migrated from ‘My Indigo‘ to ‘Resist,’ the glorious “Firelight,” done with Belgian singer Jasper Steverlinck. It’s very reminiscent of Kate Bush, with a hypnotic vocal loop that acts almost like percussion, a powerful, bursting chorus, den Adel’s delicate soprano, and an appealingly jangly guitar solo.

Den Adel was thrilled by the comparison – “That’s a big compliment, I’m a huge fan of hers,” she said,

We made it a little bit darker (than it was on the solo album), but it’s already a very dark song,” she said. “It’s about love – no matter what, it always is in the way. You don’t break with certain people. Certain things you would break with other people, but with certain people, you can’t break because it’s blood, and you never break with blood.



The soaring, poignant “Supernova” was written in memory of den Adel’s father. It’s about letting go of someone, of waiting for a divine sign that they have passed safely to the other side, and of continuing to long for their presence.

He was really hanging to life til the very last moment – he fought for every day – and that was such an inspirational time for me,” she said. “In the beginning, it was very difficult for him to accept he was sick, he was denying it, (and) I saw that as a weakness in a way. But eventually, my feelings about that changed, because I saw that’s the only way for him to continue to fight. They live one street away from where I live – I was there almost every day for three years.

“My dad didn’t believe in an afterlife; he was never religious. But I’m more of a spiritual person. I’m hoping for him to give me a sign,” she added.

The idea of resisting also carries over to categorization and labels, like the ever-present “female-fronted metal” tag, for instance.

I think it’s so much in everyone’s system to call it that,” den Adel said, “I don’t mind that it’s called that, but I do think it doesn’t really sum it up, because all these women are (doing) something totally different. The music is very different – just because they’re all female, they’re all called ‘female-fronted bands.’”

After all, no one calls other bands “male-fronted.” Or asks male singers how they balance business and family life.

People always ask me about my kids, ‘how do you combine it?’,” she said. “You don’t ask this to Ozzy! Why does everybody always ask me how do I combine them? Why? Because I have the greatest husband – he’s home, he’s taking care of them. We’re living in the modern world, we do everything 50-50.

In the end, just maybe, “female-fronted” might be an entity unto itself.

It’s just a genre on its own; it doesn’t have anything to do with any other bands,” den Adel said. “But maybe also, it’s a genre of its own and it’s not at the same time, because it’s all so different.

Ultimately, though, label WITHIN TEMPTATION by the music it offers, not the gender of its members.

We’re a symphonic metal band – please call it that,” den Adel said. “Don’t call it a ‘female-fronted band,’ because it doesn’t say anything about the guys. I’ve got five guys in the band, come on! It’s just one of me!



, , , , , , , ,